Skip to main content

Good Boy: A Dark Tale Of The Loyalty Of A Dog

I have really been wanting to write a review of the movie Good Boy, since seeing on opening day. 

This was honestly my most anticipated horror movie of 2025, although I admit the bar this year is extremely low. After being gravely disappointed by Weapons, I go into everything with low expectations. 

But, as a dog lover and also a lover of experimental horror, Good Boy was a must see.

I have to admit, though, I was also scared for this one.

As a child, I absolutely refused to watch any movie where I thought the dog might die. I'm not sure if any of my fellow 90s kids recall a movie called Fluke, but I watched that as a child and it left me positively traumatized. (Looking back, it was extremely dark subject matter for a movie aimed at children and families...dog death aside, even. I don't think my eight or nine year old self was ready to learn so much about death in general.) My mother used to offer to rent me movies about dogs, one specific one that sticks out is My Dog Skip, and I absolutely refused. I would only watch dog-centric movies if it was absolutely for certain that the dog did not die. 

Though it did not exist in my youth, I am grateful that we now have doesthedogdie.com to assist us with choosing movies carefully.

Speaking of, entries on the site said that the dog in Good Boy did not, in fact, die, but the movie was so new that I wasn't sure how trustworthy that was. And so I decided to brave it, knowing that it could very much happen. This was a horror movie, after all. 

But, I am happy to report that Indy the dog survives the movie, and gets what I suppose would be the happiest ending given the situation. 

There's not much I can really say about the plot of the movie itself...dog moves to secluded old house with sickly owner, dog starts seeing strange things the owner can't see and reacting to them...I can't really give a play-by-play without it sounding redundant, but seeing all of this from the point of view of a dog was very interesting. It reminded me of being in a dream, where you want to scream or speak, but can't. Indy the dog's expressions were also so spot on...You'd never know he wasn't actually looking at some supernatural entity when this was filmed. 

What I really wanted to talk about, though, was my theory on what the "supernatural entity" actually represented. 

The movie opens with Todd, Indy's owner, coughing up blood. It's implied he's been sick for some time, though what his ailment is is never specifically stated. For some reason, he decides to move up to an old, secluded creepy house that had previously belonged to his grandfather. While there, Indy begins seeing a dark presence looming around the house, and also starts to have visions of Todd's grandfather, his death, and also visions of the grandfather's dog and what he saw as his own owner was dying. 

Todd mentions once on a walk through a family cemetery, that many of his relatives died up there, and most of them died young. At one point, Todd's sister, Vera, mentions that Indy may be acting strangely because dogs can sense sickness.

Which brings me to my theory.

I don't think there was a supernatural entity in the house at all. I think Indy was seeing a manifestation of whatever Todd had wrong with him, and the movie was ultimately a metaphor for watching someone you love die and not being able to do anything about it, but staying loyal up until the end.

About halfway through the movie, I started to draw parallels to American Horror Story: NYC, the season in which the main villain was an entity known as "Big Daddy." Big Daddy never spoke or even really interacted much with anyone, but always seemed to be present when someone died or some sort of perilous event was happening to the main characters. Ultimately, it turned out that Big Daddy was never a person or even a ghost or demon. He was meant to represent a physical manifestation of AIDS, which was rampant during the time period in which the season is set. 

(Big Daddy as he appeared to victims in a hospital.)

And that's what I see in Good Boy. The monster doesn't represent something supernatural. It's simply the generational curse of whatever disease seems to be rampant in Todd's family, and the dogs, both Indy and the dog that had belonged to Todd's grandfather, were able to sense it and see it as this evil thing taking over their owners' lives, trying to pull them under. The dogs feel compelled to fight this thing, though they're never quite sure what it actually is, all they know is that it's threatening the life of the person they love the most. Through the innocent eyes of a dog, some malignant disease changing their owner in terrifying ways, would most definitely look like a demon constantly poised to attack. 

Good Boy did a fantastic job of portraying the love and devotion of a dog, and it was so interesting, at the end of the movie, to see how it was actually filmed, with Indy just doing his thing around his own home, with the shots of what he was supposedly reacting to added later. Indy's performance is easily one of my favorites in horror this year, but I'm always a little biased toward a cute dog.

If anyone is wondering how traumatic the ending is, it's sad, but not as bad as it could have been. Vera ultimately comes to collect Indy after Todd's passing, and while he considers just waiting down in the strange cellar of the old house, where he witnessed Todd's soul get taken away by the entity in his visions, and where the bones of the grandfather's dog still lie, Indy goes with her, and through the credits we see him riding shotgun with his head out the window, back home with her. 

There are some moments of peril for Indy, most notably a scene where is almost choked to death by a trap meant for a fox, and another where Todd's frustration with his illness leads him to chain Indy outside in a storm, but there's nothing as nearly hard to watch as I was expecting, which is a good thing. One of the most upsetting images is probably that of the grandfathers dog's bones in the cellar, especially when you think about how long he likely waited there out of loyalty to his owner. 

Good Boy, while not really what I was expecting, is definitely one of my favorite movies that I've seen this year. Here's hoping for all the Indy merch very soon. This good boy is a true horror icon. 

Stay spooky, my friends.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

I Saw The Great Pumpkin Out For A Stroll//October 233rd, 2025

  The most amazing thing happened to me, on a Saturday afternoon.  The date was August 30th, just two days before Labor Day; the start of September, and, thankfully, the unofficial (but official, in my book) end of summer.  I wound up at a local toy shop, coming away with some tiny plushies. (Two of them Christmas themed, ironically, as I am working toward finding the magic in all things once more .) As I exited the store, something caught my eye beyond the fence leading to the next residential street.  A very tall pumpkin man seemed to be walking toward a house. My mind snapped back to when I was six years old, the very first time the Great Pumpkin came to visit me. How I'd heard him in the night, a candle rattling around in his head as he did his work, ensuring the happiest of Halloweens for the truest of believers. How special it felt to know I was one of his Chosen.  I'd always hoped to thank him one day. I quietly tiptoed around the fence, out into the narr...

Pumpkin Guts: Devil’s Night//October 277th, 2024

 I was recently given the opportunity to check out a new, independent Halloween short film called Pumpkin Guts: Devil’s Night.  (Picture from IMDb) I first became aware of this film through the  Instagram page , and to say I absolutely knew beyond a shadow of a doubt that I’d love it, would be an understatement. I can always tell when a piece of media is truly going to radiate Halloween, in the way that will transport me through whatever month we’re currently in (in this case, probably the most disgusting July on record) and into Halloween night itself. When I was offered early access to this short film, I could not have been more honored. Even though I’ve built up somewhat of a following within the Halloween community, it still amazes me every day that people finally truly see and feel what I’m trying to create; that my love of Halloween finally means something and brings some joy and comfort to others like myself, and that anyone, especially a filmmaker, would trust me ...

My (Brutally?) Honest Thoughts On 'Weapons'//October 312th, 2025

 I recently saw possibly the most hyped up horror of the 2025 season, Weapons.  There have not been many movies I've been excited to see in 2025. The only horror movies I've seen in theaters this year have been Companion, Heart Eyes, and The Monkey. Other than that, nothing has really interested me enough to spend money on seeing it in theaters. (I do need to watch Sinners; scheduling conflicts kept arising when it came to seeing that one on the big screen.) But I absolutely loved the initial marketing for  Weapons, making it look like footage from a real unsolved case, and it   has easily been one of my most anticipated movies of the year. But, sadly, I actually didn't like it.  This is not meant to be a "hot take" post in any way. I'm not here to rain on anyone's parade that did enjoy it, I just have a lot of thoughts about it that I want to unpack for myself, and maybe for anyone else who feels similarly. If you loved the movie, I'm honestly very ha...